Should I Rent a Car in Hawaii or Use Uber?

Trying to decide between renting a car or using Uber in Hawaii? The answer depends on your island, budget, and travel style. While Uber and Lyft can be convenient, they’re not available everywhere—and costs can add up fast. Here’s a breakdown of both options so you can make the best choice for your Hawaiian adventure.

When Renting a Car Makes More Sense

• You want to explore beyond resort areas or off-the-beaten-path attractions
• You plan to visit beaches, scenic drives, or multiple towns
• You’re traveling with a family or a group (Uber costs add up)
• You prefer flexibility without waiting on a ride

When Uber (or Lyft) Might Work Better

• You’re staying in a walkable area like Waikiki
• You don’t plan on many day trips
• You’re only visiting for a short stay
• You want to avoid rental car parking fees

Availability by Island

Oahu

Uber and Lyft are widely available in Honolulu and Waikiki, with occasional coverage on the North Shore. Still, if you want to visit the North Shore, beaches, or remote hikes, a rental car is highly recommended.

Maui

Rideshares are limited outside of Kahului, Lahaina, and the airport. For the Road to Hana or Haleakalā, renting a car is a must.

Kauai

Rideshare coverage is minimal and unreliable. Renting a car is the best (and sometimes only) option for getting around.

Big Island

The island’s size and spread-out attractions make Uber impractical. A rental car is strongly recommended unless you’re staying entirely in one town.

Cost Comparison Example

3-day Trip in Waikiki:
Uber to/from airport + 4-5 rides around town can total $120–$150.
Economy rental car: $45/day = ~$150 + parking/insurance.
→ If you're mostly in town, Uber might save money. For flexibility and access to all of Oahu, a rental is better.